Solid vs Hydraulic lifters, oiling issues?

[SappySE107]

Is there any issue with oiling if you go from a hydraulic flat tappet lifter to a solid flat tappet lifter? Same with roller to roller I guess but the fundamentals are the same.

[TurboZ24]

I didn't have any oiling issues. They have mechanical flat tappet lifters with the "spitter" (flat spot on the side of the lifter) and there is a metering valve inside the lifter instead of the hydraulics. Crower even sells mechanical flat tappet lifters with a laser cut oiling hole on the lifter face to increase oil between the cam lobe and lifter.

On mechanical rollers, pretty much the same. I think ComCam's (the only company that has mechanical roller lifters for the 3.1) does not suggest restricting oil at all. There is a very small oil passage for the pushrod as well as a small hole to directly lubricate the roller. Now, CompCam's did mention something about durability problems when they sold the mechanical roller lifters and a cam, but I believe they actually sold a cast flat tappet cam reground with a roller profile, thus the failure, because the roller would dig into the cam lobes.

[Guest]

Crane Cams also makes roller mechanical cams and lifters for our engines as well. Its just not in the catalog. Have to call them.

But I dont' see why there would be an oiling issue. You thinking there would be an issue with the pushrod and rocker arm or with the cam and lobes themself?

[614streets]

Schneider does as well

[v6h.o.]

Schneider does as well

solid or hydraulic rollers?

how much?

[614streets]

Schneider does as well

solid or hydraulic rollers?

how much?

Solid , dont know price or details.

http://www.schneidercams.com/shop.htm

Lazer also offers roller lifters but you must mahine the block to accept.

Summit sells the Crane roller lifters one set for Bow tie , another set for std block

PAW carries the comp cam roller lifters.

[614streets]

The crane are standard v6 standard series and the bowtie has the standard or pro series option.

http://www.cranecams.com/?show=browseParts&lvl=4&prt=119&action=partSpec&partNumber=25518-12

http://www.cranecams.com/?show=browseParts&lvl=4&prt=119&action=partSpec&partNumber=25523-12

http://www.cranecams.com/?show=browseParts&lvl=4&prt=120&action=partSpec&partNumber=25543-12

[SappySE107]

Ok thanks So the only issue with solid lifters is that it still has the metering system to pump oil up the pushrod to the rockers.